REDSHIFT REPORT Subscribe

Interstellar Objects

Interstellar Comet 3I/ATLAS Carries the Heaviest Methane Ever Measured

Webb found that 1 in 30 hydrogen atoms in the comet's methane is deuterium, far above any methane in our solar system. That points to a birthplace much colder than ours.

Nov 19, 2026 · 4 min read · Episode 10

Hubble image of interstellar comet 3I/ATLAS on 30 November 2025, a bright core inside a soft blue glow
Hubble image of interstellar comet 3I/ATLAS on 30 November 2025, a bright core inside a soft blue glow. Credit: NASA, ESA, STScI, D. Jewitt (UCLA), M.-T. Hui (Shanghai Astronomical Observatory). Image Processing: J. DePasquale (STScI)

The third object ever seen passing through our solar system from another star has ice unlike anything around the Sun. Using the James Webb Space Telescope, a team led by Nathan Roth at NASA Goddard found that about one hydrogen atom in every 30 in the comet's methane is the heavy form, deuterium. No methane measured anywhere in our solar system comes close, and the result suggests the comet's ice formed somewhere extremely cold.

What they found

The comet is 3I/ATLAS. The "3I" marks it as the third interstellar object, after 'Oumuamua in 2017 and comet Borisov in 2019. A NASA-funded survey telescope in Chile called ATLAS found it on 1 July 2025. It was moving too fast to be bound to the Sun, at about 130,000 miles per hour (58 kilometers per second) even far from the Sun, so its path is an open curve. It passed closest to the Sun on 29 October 2025, just inside the orbit of Mars, and will never return.

In late December 2025, as the comet was heading back out, Webb's NIRSpec instrument measured the infrared light of gases around it. The team looked for methane in two forms: ordinary methane, CH₄, and a rarer version, CH₃D, in which one hydrogen atom is replaced by deuterium.

The heavy version was there. The ratio of deuterium to hydrogen (D/H) in the methane came out at 3.33 percent, give or take 0.31 percent. That is:

  • about 14 times the methane value for comet 67P, the only other comet where heavy methane has been measured, by Europe's Rosetta spacecraft
  • about 3.4 times the D/H of 3I/ATLAS's own water
  • higher, in the authors' words, than every other methane value measured in the solar system

How they know

Deuterium is hydrogen with an extra neutron in its nucleus. In Earth's oceans, about one hydrogen atom in 6,400 is deuterium.

When gas freezes onto dust grains in very cold places, deuterium ends up in the ice more easily than ordinary hydrogen, and the colder it is, the stronger the effect. Once that ice is locked inside a comet, the ratio can survive for billions of years. Measuring it works a bit like reading a thermometer, not for the comet today but for the place where its ice formed.

The measurement was hard. Light from heavy methane is about 100 times weaker than from ordinary methane, so the signal sat close to the noise. Webb's sensitivity in the infrared made the difference.

The water came first

Two earlier studies had already measured the comet's water. A team using the ALMA telescopes in Chile detected heavy water and found the water's D/H was at least 30 to 40 times Earth's ocean value. That is a lower limit, so the true figure could be higher. A Webb study led by Martin Cordiner, published in Nature in June 2026, measured about one deuterium atom per 100 hydrogen atoms in the water. That team also found unusual carbon isotopes and estimated the comet could be 10 to 12 billion years old, older than the Sun.

For comparison, when Rosetta measured comet 67P's water, it found roughly three times Earth's ocean value. 3I/ATLAS is in another league.

Why it matters

Every young planetary system builds comets, and some of them are thrown out into interstellar space. Each visitor is a sample of a place we cannot travel to. Deuterium ratios are one of the few tools that can tell us how cold that place was.

Chemistry that pushes deuterium this high happens in the coldest parts of a galaxy: dense clouds of gas and dust at about 10 kelvin, or roughly minus 440°F (minus 263°C). The 10 kelvin figure describes that kind of environment, not a temperature measured for this comet. The authors suggest the ices formed in a cold, low-metal environment with strong exposure to cosmic rays. Methane in both 3I/ATLAS and 67P is richer in deuterium than their water, which may mean the methane formed later than the water and had more time for this chemistry to work.

Separately, studies of the comet's speed and direction suggest it may come from the Milky Way's thick disk, an older population of stars. Combined with the age estimate, that hints the comet's ice may have frozen long before Earth existed.

What is still uncertain

The birthplace is an inference, not a measurement. The authors write that it is uncertain whether current models of star formation or disk chemistry can reproduce a methane ratio this high. Teams studying the comet also weigh the role of radiation in different ways. The comet's age is a statistical estimate based on its motion and composition, not a direct date. And the methane value should not be compared one to one with ocean water, because methane and water pick up deuterium differently.

When 3I/ATLAS first appeared, some people suggested it might be artificial. Every measurement since, including a glowing coma, a tail and gas rich in carbon dioxide, shows it behaves like a natural icy comet.

The paper

"An enriched methane D/H ratio in the interstellar object 3I/ATLAS" by Nathan X. Roth and colleagues, including Martin Cordiner, Stefanie Milam and Geronimo Villanueva, was published in Nature Astronomy on 23 October 2026. It is based on Webb NIRSpec observations of the comet's coma on 22 and 23 December 2025. The supporting water results come from Salazar Manzano, Paneque-Carreño et al. (Nature Astronomy, 2026) and Cordiner et al. (Nature, 2026). The full story is in our Redshift Report episode.

More from Redshift